Why Sympathy & Anger Do Not Inspire Jurors to Award Large Damages

by | Mar 6, 2014 | Personal Injury | 0 comments

Anger

Although anger is usually a very forceful inspiration for action, an experienced Michigan injury lawyer knows that merely provoking anger in jurors will not necessarily result in a large damages award.

It is not effective just to tell jurors that you are really angry about what happened to you and that they should be angry too. To truly inspire jurors to act, your Michigan personal injury lawyer must actually help the jurors experience the anger for themselves. When an attorney expresses anger without the jurors feeling it too, the jurors may either fail to respond at all or subconsciously feel that they are the target of the anger. While communal anger is potent, it is disturbing to be on the receiving end of the anger, even when a juror knows consciously that the anger is aimed at someone else.

Anger is a sensation, not an ethical principle. Sensations are transitory, but principles are more permanent. To inspire a juror to act, anger must be connected to an ethical principle, not just a temporary feeling. The ethical principle needs to be one that the jurors directly believe in and identify to be worth standing up for.

If you or someone you love has sustained injuries in an auto accident, and you would like to speak with an experienced Michigan injury lawyer about the potential value of your case, please contact us.

Sympathy

Similarly, sympathy is not a feeling that inspires most jurors to lean significantly in favor of an injured plaintiff. Despite what “tort reform” supporters will have you believe, juries are not always biased towards injury victims. In addition, most jury instructions (the formal instructions on the law that the judge reads to the jurors before they begin deliberations) clearly state that jurors are not to decide the case based on sympathy. This provides jurors leaning toward the defense with arguments to aggressively rebut any sympathy expressed in the jury room. In fact, if jurors believe that the plaintiff is trying to appeal to their sympathy, they may feel resentful and hostile towards the plaintiff.

If you would like to speak with an experienced Michigan injury lawyer about the principles in your case that will motivate jurors, please contact us.


Request A Free Consultation Below

[contact-form-7 id=”30″ title=”Contact form”]

Cadillac, MI – Child Injured in Bicycle Crash at Granite & Laurel St

Cadillac, MI (June 3, 2023) - A 12-year-old boy was hurt while riding a bike in Cadillac on Friday night, June 2.  The fatal accident was reported at the corner of Granite and Laurel Street at around 6:40 p.m. The victim was traveling by bicycle when he was hit by a...

Algonac, MI – Debra Fox Killed in Boating Accident at Algonac Harbor Club

Algonac, MI (June 3, 2023) - A Clarkston woman was killed in a boating accident in Algonac over the weekend on Friday, May 26.  The deadly accident took place at the Algonac Harbor Club on M-29 near State Street. When emergency responders arrived, they found a 23-foot...

Imlay City, MI – Woman Killed, Man Hurt in Can-Am Spyder Motorcycle Crash on M-53

Imlay City, MI (June 3, 2023) - A woman was killed and a man injured following a crash involving two motorcycles in Imlay City on Sunday afternoon, May 28.  The fatal accident was reported on M-53 as the woman was riding a Can-Am Spyder three-wheeled motorcycle and...

Flint Twp, MI – Two Killed, One Hurt in Wrong-Way Crash at I-75 & Beecher Rd

Flint Twp, MI (June 3, 2023) - A head-on crash in Flint Township on Saturday, May 27, left two people dead and another in critical condition.  At around 10:35 p.m., two vehicles collided on Interstate 75 near Beecher Road. It was reported that a 43-year-old man from...

Holly Twp, MI – Burton Man Killed in Motorcycle Crash at Belford & Holly Rd

Holly Twp, MI (June 3, 2023) - On Monday, May 29, a motorcyclist was killed following a collision in Holly Township.  The deadly accident was reported at the intersection of Belford and Holly Roads early that morning. A 53-year-old Burton man was headed northbound on...

Gladwin, MI – Woman Hurt in Three-Vehicle Crash on M-61

Gladwin, MI (June 3, 2023) - A woman was injured after a pileup collision in the Gladwin area on Tuesday, May 23.  The accident was reported on M-61 that afternoon. Three vehicles reportedly collided at the scene. A woman was hurt in the crash, and she was treated at...

Kingsford, MI – Two Hurt after Car Crashes into Healthcare Building on Pyle Dr

Kingsford, MI (June 3, 2023) - Two people were injured after a vehicle crashed into a building on Pyle Drive in Kingsford on Thursday afternoon, June 1.  The accident occurred as a 2003 Ford Crown Victoria was traveling on the roadway and crashed into the Northpointe...

Walker, MI – Driver Seriously Hurt in Two-Car Crash at Elmridge Dr & 3 Mile Rd

Walker, MI (June 3, 2023) - Two people were injured after a two-vehicle collision in Walker on Wednesday, May 31.  The accient was reported at the intersection of Elmrige Drive and 3 Mile Road at around 8 a.m. A driver was making a left turn when they were hit by an...

Frenchtown Twp, MI – Monroe Man Dies in 18-Wheeler Crash at Telegraph & Newport Rd

Frenchtown Twp, MI (June 2, 2023) - On Monday, May 29, a Monroe man was killed after being hit by a semi-truck in Frenchtown Township.  The victim was riding a 1989 Honda Hurricane motorcycle when he was hit by a black 2020 Peterbilt tractor-trailer at the...

Gaines Twp, MI – Britt Bridge Killed in Motorcycle Accident at Morrish & Hill Rd

Gaines Twp, MI (June 2, 2023) - A crash involving a pickup truck and a motorcycle in Gaines Township resulted in the death of a Swartz Creek man on Saturday, May 27.  The deadly crash occurred at the corner of Morrish and Hill Roads at around 11 p.m. that night. It...