DUI Stops That Are Based on Anonymous Tips: Unlawful in Many States

by | Sep 19, 2016 | DUI | 0 comments

Any skilled Michigan DUI defense attorney can tell you that there have been a variety of state court cases that have deemed that DUI stops that were made based on anonymous tips were unlawful.

For example, in the state of Texas, an anonymous tipster phoned the county sheriff’s department to say that he or she had seen a red pickup truck going the wrong way in the northbound lane. At that time, the informant’s identity was unknown, as was the informant’s reliability and location at the time of the spotting. Accordingly, the Texas court found the stop unlawful, noting that caution must be taken in the reliance of an anonymous tip because the tip, on its own, will rarely provide the requisite reasonable suspicion necessary to authorize an investigative stop and detention.

Another example is a Georgia case in which an anonymous tip was left without the inclusion of specific details; it was found insufficient to justify a DUI stop. The court noted that the tip was not particularly predictive of the driver’s future behavior by which its reliability could be tested. More specifically, the tip, alone, provided virtually nothing from which one might conclude that the caller was either honest or his information reliable; similarly, the tip gave absolutely no clue as to what the basis was for the caller’s predictions with respect to the suspect’s criminal activities.

If you need a qualified Michigan DUI defense attorney, call Chris Trainor at (800) 961 – 8477.

 

Detroit, MI – Man Fatally Hit by Motor Vehicle on I-95 near I-75

Detroit, MI (June 1, 2023) - A Woodhaven man was killed after being hit by a car in Detroit on Tuesday, May 30.  At around 10:05 p.m., emergency responders were dispatched to the scene on Interstate 95 near Interstate 75. A 40-year-old motorist had reportedly run...

Inland Twp, MI – Woman on Bike Killed in Crash at Fewins & Lake Ann Rd

Inland Twp, MI (June 1, 2023) - A woman from Interlochen was killed after being hit while riding a bicycle in Inland Township on Saturday, May 27.  The fatal crash occurred early that morning at the intersection of Fewins and Lake Ann Roads at around 1:30 a.m....

Georgetown Twp, MI – Two Motorcyclists Ejected in Crash at Port Sheldon St & Chicago Dr

Georgetown Twp, MI (June 1, 2023) - Two motorcycle riders were hurt after an accident on Tuesday, May 30, in the area of Georgetown Township.  At around 1:02 p.m., it was reported that a motorcycle had crashed on Port Sheldon Street near Chicago Drive. A...

Banks Twp, MI – One Killed, Another Hurt in Head-On Crash at US-81 & Old Dixie Hwy

Banks Twp, MI (June 1, 2023) - A crash involving two pickup trucks in Banks Township left one person dead and another injured on Wednesday, May 31.  The deadly accident took place on US-81 near Old Dixie Highway at around 2:15 p.m. It was reported that a 2020...

Grand Rapids, MI – Several Hurt in Car Accident at Curwood Ave & Langley St

Grand Rapids, MI (June 1, 2023) - There were several confirmed injuries resulting from a car crash in Grand Rapids on Friday morning, May 26, and the victims included two children.  The crash occurred at around 9:30 at the corner of Curwood Avenue and Langley...

Dearborn, MI – Injuries Reported in Rollover Crash at Michigan Ave & Greenfield Rd

Dearborn, MI (June 1, 2023) - On Wednesday, May 31, a pileup crash in Dearborn left at least one person with injuries.  At around 6 a.m., the accident took place at the corner of Michigan Avenue and Greenfield Road. It was reported that at least one vehicle and an SUV...

Dundee, MI – Four Injured in Crash Involving Wrong-Way Driver on US-23

Dundee, MI (June 1, 2023) - A multi-vehicle crash involving a wrong-way driver left several people injured in Dundee on Tuesday, May 30.  The accident occurred that morning at around 8 a.m. on US-23. A 38-year-old driver from Plymouth was traveling in the wrong...

Lansing, MI – Driver Hurt in Crash with Semi-Trailer at I-69 & Vermontville Hwy

Lansing, MI (June 1, 2023) - On Tuesday, May 30, a driver was injured after a collision involving a semi-trailer in Lansing.  The accident was reported on Interstate 69 NB near Vermontville Highway at around 4:08 p.m. A gold SUV was traveling southbound when it...

Walker, MI – Motorcyclist Seriously Hurt in Collision at Alpine Ave & Hillside Dr

Walker, MI (May 31, 2023) - A motorcyclist suffered serious injuries after being involved in an accident with another vehicle in Walker on Tuesday night, May 30.  The crash occurred at the intersection of Alpine Avenue and Hillside Drive at around 5 p.m. It was...

Grand Rapids, MI – Two Hurt in Crash with Wrong-Way Driver at US-131 & Hall St

Grand Rapids, MI (May 31, 2023) - On Saturday, May 27, a crash involving a wrong-way driver and a police cruiser in Grand Rapids resulted in confirmed injuries.  The accident was reported at around 11 p.m. on US-131 near Hall Street. A state trooper witnessed a...