What are the Laws Governing Unconstitutional Searches?

by | Jun 8, 2020 | Civil Rights | 0 comments

In 2014, a man was arrested in Michigan on charges of possession of marijuana and meth, and given a two-to-10 year prison sentence. The case started after the man, Larry Mead, accepted a ride in a vehicle that got pulled over by police because it had an expired plate. The drugs that led to Mead’s criminal charges were in his backpack.

But now Mead’s conviction has been thrown out by the Michigan Supreme Court, which ruled that his rights were violated when police searched his backpack without his consent. In ruling that the search was unconstitutional, the Michigan Supreme Court also strengthened the legal standard for searching people during a traffic stop — including passengers.

While this ruling only applies to the state of Michigan, all Americans are protected from unconstitutional searches thanks to the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which guarantees every citizen’s right to be free from unreasonable government intrusion, including police stops. If you believe your civil rights were violated by an illegal search, it’s important to get assistance right away from a civil rights attorney with experience handling illegal or improper searches.

Why Did the Michigan Supreme Court Rule Against the Backpack Search?

Over the years, legal safeguards have been put in place that allow law enforcement officers to interfere with a citizen’s Fourth Amendment rights under limited circumstances. Those protections apply to someone pulled over for a minor traffic violation. In most instances, a police officer can’t search someone’s property unless they have a valid search warrant or arrest warrant, or can demonstrate to the courts that there was “probable cause” that the person had committed a crime.

In Mead’s case, he had accepted a ride from a woman he had just met, her vehicle got pulled over for a minor infraction by a sheriff’s deputy, and the deputy then looked inside Mead’s backpack after the driver consented to a search of her car. The deputy found marijuana and methamphetamine in Mead’s backpack, and he was eventually arrested, convicted as a fourth-offense habitual offender, and sentenced to prison. 

Mead challenged the search and argued that his rights had been violated, and the Michigan Supreme Court agreed. In ruling that the search was unconstitutional, the justices also decided that Mead had a legitimate expectation of privacy when he was in that car. 

Chief Justice Bridget McCormack noted that Mead was a passenger in the car and compared this situation to someone using a ride-sharing service. McCormick said police could not search a passenger based on consent given by an Uber or Lyft driver. 

The court unanimously ruled that:

“A person can get in a car without leaving his Fourth Amendment rights at the curb … Because (the driver) did not have apparent common authority over the backpack, the search of the backpack was not based on valid consent and is per se unreasonable unless another exception to the warrant requirement applies.”

Did this Court Ruling Change Michigan Law?

Legal experts in Michigan called this a significant ruling that would likely impact police training methods across the state. The Michigan Commission on Law Enforcement Standards, which sets training guidelines at the state’s basic training academies, has reviewed its curriculum in response to the court’s decision.

David Moran, a University of Michigan law professor, said this ruling helped correct an error in the law. He noted:

“The Fourth Amendment is all about common sense and reasonable expectations of privacy and social norms. It’s just common sense that the police will now need to ask passengers, ‘Mind if I search that bag?’”

The ruling also reinforces the importance of the Fourth Amendment as a constitutional guarantee of our right to privacy. What’s key for ensuring those rights work for you is for every American to understand their rights, and know when they can refuse to consent to a search. 

Not everyone who has a confrontation with the police will know if their Fourth Amendment rights have been violated, such as when an arrest violates the Fourth Amendment because it wasn’t supported by probable cause or a valid warrant. But if that’s what happened, any evidence obtained through that unlawful arrest, including a confession, will be kept out of the case.

That’s why if you were arrested after a search of your home, vehicle or other property, it’s important to immediately contact an attorney who understands the complex rules of search and seizure and will let you know if there were any problems with the search that could result in evidence being thrown out of court. An experienced criminal defense attorney should review the search and seizure procedures used in the case against you.

Experienced Michigan Civil Rights Attorneys Here to Help

All Michigan residents should have full protection of their civil rights under the law. If you or something you know believes your civil rights have been violated, including when police are conducting a search to gather evidence, we can help defend those rights. The Fourth Amendment exists to protect your rights in situations like this, and you have the right to refuse to provide consent for a search.

If you’ve been the victim of any kind of police misconduct, consult the attorneys at the Michigan Legal Center. We specialize in protecting our clients from illegal and improper searches, and with more than 20 years of experience and more than $200 million worth of legal cases, we’re here to defend the residents of Michigan. Call 1-800-961-8447 for your free consultation.

Detroit, MI – Car Crash Causes Injuries on I-696 at M-10

Detroit, MI (September 21, 2023) - According to an initial accident alert issued by the Detroit Police Department, a multiple-vehicle collision that occurred on Thursday, September 21, necessitated the involvement of local officers and EMTs. Additionally, the Michigan...

Detroit, MI – Two-Vehicle Collision w/Injuries at Garfield & 14 Mile

Detroit, MI (September 21, 2023) - At least one individual was injured on the afternoon of Thursday, September 21, due to an accident involving two or three vehicles that occurred on Garfield Road in Detroit. The collision occurred around 2:30 p.m. in the afternoon on...

Detroit, MI – Injury-Causing Accident on 14 Mile Rd at Groesbeck Hwy

Detroit, MI (September 21, 2023) - On Thursday evening, September 21, police were called to an accident involving two to three vehicles in the greater Detroit area. On Thursday at around 11:30 p.m. in the evening, there was an accident near the corner of 14 Mile Road...

Lansing, MI – Two Hospitalized in Pedestrian Wreck on Jolly Rd

Lansing, MI (September 21, 2023) - Two persons were hit by a vehicle Thursday night and sustained minor injuries, per officers from the Lansing Police Department. The accident occurred in the 2500 block of East Jolly Road. Lansing Police reported that both victims...

Detroit, MI – I-94 Site of Injury Car Accident at Concord Rd

Detroit, MI (September 21, 2023) - On Thursday, September 21, two or three drivers crashed on eastbound Interstate 94 in the city of Detroit, resulting in at least one injury. At around 6:00 a.m., an accident occurred in the eastbound lanes of Interstate 94 near the...

Grand Rapids, MI – Worker Killed in Jobsite Accident at Briggs Field

Grand Rapids, MI (September 21, 2023) - On Wednesday, September 19, a worker for Grand Rapids Public Schools was killed in a job site accident. At noon, while working at Briggs Field Athletic Facility, an employee was injured while riding a lawnmower.  The exact...

Detroit, MI – Injuries Recorded in Vehicle Wreck on M-39 at Joy Rd

Detroit, MI (September 21, 2023) - On Thursday morning, September 21, officers with the Detroit Police Department received a collision alert and a report of injuries at the scene of a multiple-vehicle accident on Highway 39. Right around 8:45 a.m. on the northbound...

Portage, MI – Teen Hit, Injured in Pedestrian Wreck on Kilgore Rd

Portage, MI (September 21, 2023) - Nick Armold, the chief of the Portage Department of Public Safety, stated that on Thursday morning, one of three 15-year-old girls heading to Loy Norrix High School was hit by a car. Armold said that the girls had been walking on the...

Detroit, MI – Car Accident, Injuries on I-696 at Orchard Lake

Detroit, MI (September 20, 2023) - On September 20, officers with the Detroit Police Department received a collision alert and a report of injuries at the scene of a multiple-vehicle accident on Interstate 696. Right around 9:00 a.m. on the eastbound side of the...

Kalamazoo, MI – Pedestrian Hospitalized in Crash on King Hwy at Mills

Kalamazoo, MI (September 20, 2023) - On Wednesday, a pedestrian was struck by a vehicle in Kalamazoo, according to the department. Traffic was blocked due to the accident on King Highway near Mills Street, and it was requested that motorists find an alternative route....