Are There Racial Disparities in Police Use of Force Cases?

by | Mar 3, 2020 | Criminal Defense, Police Brutality | 0 comments

Recent high-profile cases of police shootings of African Americans have raised widespread concerns and questions about the extent of racial disparities in fatal officer-involved shootings.

In the past few years, a number of different studies have been done to see if the belief that so many Americans have about a racial disparity were true. While some past studies have indicated there’s not enough data to draw that conclusion, one recent study definitively took the opposite view.

For many, their central assumption is that the racial bias of the individual officers plays a key role, while studies have also indicated that economics can be a major factor as well. Let’s take a closer look at how to answer the question of whether there are racial disparities in police use of force cases.

Are there Racial Disparities in Use of Force Cases?

Police shootings of African-Americans have prompted considerable outrage and led in part to the Black Lives Matter movement and even a presidential task force on policing. So are Black civilians overrepresented in fatal officer-involved shootings, and is this due to racial discrimination by white officers?

A recent study by the National Bureau of Economic Research titled “Does Race Matter for Police Use of Force?” concluded that “identifying causal effects is difficult” because researchers typically only look at altercations between police and civilians that end in use of force, and not cases that didn’t. However, a study of two major cities drew some strong conclusions just the same.

This study used data from more than 2 million 911 calls in those two unnamed cities. They found that:

  • White officers used force 60 percent more often than black officers
  • White officers used gun force twice as often
  • White and black officers use gun force at similar rates in both white and racially mixed neighborhoods
  • White officers were five times more likely to use gun force in predominantly black neighborhoods
  • White officers use force more frequently in minority neighborhoods than minority officers do

Their findings, the researchers concluded, indicate race is clearly a strong indicator of whether police will use force, especially lethal force.

Part of their research focused on those 911 calls, and the way in which officers are assigned to respond to them. Since the officers don’t get to choose which calls to respond to, the study found that a call was more likely to result in force when a white officer is assigned to a minority neighborhood.  

Why Do Police Use Greater Force in Minority Neighborhoods?

Statistics have clearly indicated that in many minority neighborhoods across the nation, there’s a solid lack of faith and trust in the very people assigned to protect them. That includes a 2016 Pew Research Center survey that found that African Americans are less than half as likely to trust police as white residents. While 75 percent of white people said police do an excellent or good job,  just 35 percent of black people responded the same way. 

This has raised concerns about the extent to which police are failing in a key mission: to protect residents in black communities. Aggressive policing methods, which may have been originally intended to target criminals in low-income communities, have led to far too many victims who were not committing crimes being subject to deadly force as well.

Another analysis by Dara Lind on FBI data found that police kill black people at disproportionate rates, with blacks representing 31 percent of police killing victims in 2012, even though they’re just 13 percent of the U.S. population.  Some research indicates that if there’s a disparity between how police respond to white and minority neighborhoods, socioeconomic factors like poverty can play a role as well. 

In other words, if poverty and unemployment are high in a particular neighborhood, there may be an assumption by police that the neighborhood will experience higher rates of crime and violence as well, so there’s a need to take tougher policing actions there, whether it’s through traffic stops or more frequent arrests. In turn, the officers may believe it’s generally more dangerous to patrol these neighborhoods, which in their mind justifies an enhanced use of force.

Experienced Michigan Police Misconduct Attorneys Here to Help

Your rights should never be violated. If you’ve been the victim of police misconduct, consult the attorneys at the Michigan Legal Center. We specialize in protecting our clients from all manner of police brutality and misconduct. With more than 20 years of experience and more than $200 million worth of legal cases, we’re here to defend the residents of Michigan.

The attorneys at the Michigan Legal Center are happy to answer any questions and offer advice on the necessary steps to receive compensation after experiencing the consequences of police misconduct. Call 1-800-961-8447 for your free consultation.

Christopher Trainor and Associates Featured on WXYZ

Recently Christopher Trainor and Associates was featured on WXYZ 7 Action News in Detroit regarding a client's case against the Detroit Police Department in which the client was wrongly arrested and held in jail. The full article and can be found on the WXYZ website.

St Joseph, MI – Injuries Result from Wreck on I-94 near Martin Luther King Dr

St Joseph, MI (March 25, 2022) - A major car crash happened on an interstate in St Joseph on the afternoon of March 20. At approximately 5:10 p.m., an unspecified number of vehicles collided on Interstate 94. Reports show the accident happened on I-94 near Martin...

Zeeland, MI – Auto Accident on Fairview Rd at Washington Ave Ends in Injuries

Zeeland, MI (March 25, 2022) - An auto accident happened on the morning of March 25 in Zeeland that resulted in injuries. The wreck occurred shortly after 8:00 a.m., according to reports.  Sources say the collision took place on Fairview Road near Washington...

Paw Paw, MI – Major Car Crash on M-43 between 37th & 40th St

Paw Paw, MI (March 25, 2022) - A motor vehicle accident occurred in Paw Paw on the morning of March 23 that required an emergency response. The incident was reported to authorities in the area at around 12:21 p.m. Various responders were observed at the scene of the...

Romulus, MI – Motor Vehicle Collision Causes Injuries on I-94 near Vining Rd

Romulus, MI (March 25, 2022) - At least one person was hurt in a crash reported in Romulus on March 25. At approximately 12:55 p.m., police were dispatched to the scene of the wreck located on Interstate 94.  Responders including paramedics, fire crews, and...

Holland, MI – Injury Accident on Waverly Rd at 48th St Requires EMT Dispatch

Holland, MI (March 25, 2022) - On the morning of March 25, at approximately 6:55 a.m., a car accident in Holland required an emergency dispatch.  Reports indicate that a vehicle collided with a pole near 48th Street on Waverly Road.  To assist the injured...

Jackson, MI – Serious Car Accident on M-106 near Deweese Rd and Hawkins Rd

Jackson, MI (March 25, 2022) - Police officers in Jackson were dispatched to the scene of a major car crash on Friday, March 25. According to local officials, the collision happened at approximately 4:00 p.m. on M-106. While emergency personnel rendered aid to those...

Detroit, MI – Police Dispatched to Crash Scene on I-96 near Davison St

Detroit, MI (March 25, 2022) - On March 25, at least one person was injured in a car accident in Detroit. The wreck was reported to officials in the area at approximately 10:50 p.m. According to information from reports, the accident occurred on I-96 near Davison...

Wyoming, MI – Major Accident on 28th St near Clyde Park Ave

Wyoming, MI (March 24, 2022) - Highway patrol officers and first responders were called to the scene of a vehicle collision on March 24 on 28th Street in Wyoming. Reports show that an unspecified number of vehicles collided in the area, resulting in the injury of at...

St Clair, MI – Siblings Killed in Wreck on Kinney Rd near Burt Rd

St Clair, MI (March 24, 2022) - A brother and sister were killed in a two-car crash on Thursday, March 24 in Riley Township. The incident was reported north of Interstate 69 on Kinney Road near Burt Road.  Three people were also hospitalized with injuries,...